Every club personally tasted, scored, and assessed. Filter by your preference and find the one built for you.
Showing 13 clubs — sorted by expert score.
Roscioli is Rome's most celebrated wine cellar and deli, with relationships built across Italian wine country over five decades. Their club ships bottles that simply don't exist in the export market — rare producers, unusual grapes, and wines that make you rethink what Italian wine can be.
Over thirty years finding small California wineries that most people will never hear about, and delivering their wine to subscribers at prices that make the alternatives look overpriced. The Case Club tier in particular is one of the strongest value propositions in wine subscriptions anywhere.
Naked Wines runs on a deceptively simple idea: wine drinkers fund independent winemakers directly, and in return get access to bottles they could never find in a shop. Four consecutive years as America's #1 rated wine club. I've been a member for three of them, and the ranking is not wrong.
Every review on this site is based on actual bottles received and tasted — not press releases or marketing copy. We score each club on wine quality, value, flexibility, customer service, and shipping reliability. Scores are updated whenever a club changes its pricing or quality.
Learn About Our Review Process →